Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare your projected net worth from buying a home versus renting and investing the difference, over the time you plan to stay.
by approximately $47,689 in net worth.
- Buying
- Renting
Estimates assume 1% property tax, 1% annual maintenance, 3% rent inflation, and 3% selling costs. Buying net worth = home equity minus selling costs; renting net worth = down payment plus monthly savings invested at your chosen return. Adjust the inputs to match your market.
"Renting is throwing money away" is one of the most repeated lines in Canadian real estate — and one of the most misleading. Renting buys you flexibility and frees up capital you can invest elsewhere; buying builds equity but ties up a large down payment and locks you into significant transaction costs. The honest answer to which is better isn't a slogan, it's arithmetic — and it changes with your city, your timeline, and what you'd do with the money you don't spend on a home.
It's a contest between two investments
The right way to frame the decision is as two competing portfolios. Buy, and your wealth grows through home equity and any appreciation, minus mortgage interest, property tax, maintenance, and selling costs. Rent, and your wealth grows through the down payment and monthly cost difference invested in the market, minus rent. The winner is simply whichever portfolio is larger at the end of your horizon — which is exactly what the chart above projects year by year.
Why your timeline is the deciding factor
Buying carries heavy one-time costs: land transfer tax, legal fees, and roughly 3–5% in real-estate commissions and closing costs when you sell. Spread over two or three years those costs can swamp any equity you build, which is why buying for a short stay often loses. Spread over ten years they fade into the background while equity and appreciation compound. As a rough guide, the longer you'll stay put, the more buying pulls ahead — and around the seven-year mark is where it typically tips for most Canadian markets.
The factors the math can't fully capture
Numbers aside, owning brings stability, freedom to renovate, and protection from rent increases — but also maintenance headaches, property tax, and the cost and friction of moving if your job or family changes. Renting offers mobility and predictable costs but no equity and exposure to rising rents. Use the calculator to get the financial picture clear, then weigh these lifestyle factors on top. The best decision is the one where the math and your life plans point in the same direction.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to rent or buy in Canada?
It depends on how long you'll stay, local home prices, rent levels, and the return you'd earn by investing your down payment instead. Buying usually wins over long horizons of about seven years or more, as you build equity and benefit from any appreciation. Renting can win over short horizons or in very expensive markets where prices are high relative to rents.
What costs should I include when comparing rent vs buy?
Buying includes your down payment, mortgage interest, property tax, maintenance, home insurance, and one-time closing and land-transfer costs. Renting includes rent and renter's insurance — plus the investment return you'd earn on the down payment and monthly savings you didn't tie up in a home. A fair comparison counts both the costs of owning and the opportunity cost of renting.
Why does the 'years you'll stay' input matter so much?
Buying carries large one-time costs — land transfer tax, legal fees, and roughly 3–5% in selling costs when you leave. The longer you stay, the more years those fixed costs are spread across, and the more equity and appreciation you accumulate. Over a short stay those transaction costs can easily outweigh any equity gain, which is why a longer horizon usually tips the math toward buying.
Does this calculator account for home appreciation and investment returns?
Yes. You set both an annual home-appreciation rate and the return you expect on invested savings, and the chart projects each scenario's net worth year by year. This matters because the rent-vs-buy decision is really a contest between two investments: equity in a home that appreciates, versus a portfolio funded by the cash you'd otherwise spend on a down payment and higher monthly costs.
Is buying always the better long-term financial choice?
Not always. In markets where prices are very high relative to rents, a disciplined renter who invests the difference can come out ahead even over long periods. Buying also brings less obvious costs — maintenance, property tax, and reduced flexibility to move for work. The right answer is personal, which is why it helps to run your own city's prices, rents, and a realistic investment return through the tool above.
Related tools & guides
Affordability Calculator
See how much home you can buy under the Canadian stress test.
Mortgage Calculator
Estimate your full monthly payment and amortization.
Land Transfer Tax
Calculate this major closing cost in your province.
First-Time Buyer Guide
Programs, rebates, and steps for your first purchase.
CMHC Insurance
Find out the mortgage default insurance you'll owe.
Weekly Newsletter
Fresh insights on Canadian rates and the housing market.
Related guides
Ready to Buy? See What You Can Afford
Check your buying power with the Canadian mortgage stress test.